BNPL Isn’t Optional Anymore
Why Buy Now, Pay Later has become a core revenue and pricing strategy
A couple of years ago, I started seeing Buy Now, Pay Later shift from a “nice-to-have” to a revenue-driving must-have for my clients.
What began as a tool primarily for eCommerce brands to nudge hesitant buyers over the finish line has transformed into a strategic lever that boosts average order values, expands customer segments, and reduces the need for discounting.
The numbers tell a compelling story. The BNPL industry exploded from $2 billion in 2019 to nearly $34 billion by 2022.
Look at Coachella as a case study: what started as a niche payment option in 2009 with just 18% adoption is now embraced by approximately 60% of festival-goers in 2025 (source). That pattern is repeating across industries at an accelerating pace.
Why BNPL Works So Well
At its core, BNPL eases purchase anxiety.
When customers see a large upfront price, their brain kicks into risk assessment mode: Can I afford this? Is this a smart choice right now?
BNPL sidesteps that stress by breaking the decision into smaller, low-stakes commitments.
This taps into two key psychological levers:
Immediate Gratification vs. Deferred Pain – BNPL lets buyers enjoy the product now, while the “pain” of paying is spread out over time. That separation softens the impact and makes the decision feel easier.
Cognitive Load Reduction – Large purchases often trigger mental math. BNPL simplifies that process by showing a smaller number, which makes the cost feel more approachable and reduces decision fatigue.
The result? People move from “maybe later” to “why not now?” much faster.
This psychological shift is powerful enough that I’ve seen meaningful revenue lifts even on lower-priced items—simply because installment payments remove mental resistance.
It’s not always about affordability. It’s about emotional ease.
The Accessibility Factor—Without Discounting
Payment fragmentation reframes the value-to-cost equation without touching the actual price.
Instead of lowering the price through a discount, you reduce the perceived financial friction by splitting the cost into more digestible chunks.
It’s the difference between asking someone to pay $200 today vs. $50 over four months. Same price—but the latter feels more doable.
That psychological relief expands your customer base, especially for higher-ticket items, without eroding margins.
For many businesses, that’s a win-win: accessibility without undercutting brand value or profitability.
BNPL has also given businesses permission to hold the line on price—especially for premium offers. Instead of defaulting to discounts or “lite” versions to make something feel affordable, brands can now present the full value and simply offer payment flexibility.
It’s also opened the door for upselling and bundling. When customers view a purchase in monthly terms, they’re more open to add-ons or upgrades they might’ve passed on if paying all at once.
In effect, BNPL shifts the pricing conversation from “Is this too expensive?” to “Can I manage this monthly amount?”—and that unlocks a lot more freedom in how businesses position and price their offers.
Beyond Retail: Where BNPL Delivers Surprising Results
One of the most interesting shifts in BNPL adoption? It’s no longer limited to big-ticket retail or tech.
It’s showing up in wellness, education, boutique travel, and service-based businesses—anywhere there’s an emotionally significant purchase that requires a financial leap.
For example, service providers have used BNPL to open doors for clients who were emotionally ready to invest but financially hesitant. Similarly, local businesses like home improvement services have seen a boost just by adding payment flexibility at checkout.
(If you're reading this and have an example to contribute, I'd love to hear it.)
The common thread? Wherever there’s a meaningful decision that requires trust and timing, BNPL offers a softer landing—and better conversions.
Implementation Mistakes to Avoid
The biggest mistake? Treating BNPL like a checkbox instead of a strategic lever.
Too often, businesses just add the option at checkout and call it a day.
But to really see results, you have to integrate it into the entire customer journey—on sales pages, in email campaigns, and during launches—where it can actually influence decision-making before someone hits checkout.
Another common miss: not using BNPL to reframe price.
Businesses hesitate to lead with “$500,” when they could be saying “Just $125 today.” That simple shift can dramatically change perception and urgency.
And finally, some teams don’t train their sales staff or customer support on BNPL at all. If someone’s asking about affordability or payment options, that’s a prime opportunity to highlight it—but it gets missed because no one’s thinking holistically.
The Customer Relationship Impact
BNPL doesn’t just change how people buy—it changes how they feel about their purchase after the fact.
When customers feel like a brand helped them access something meaningful without financial strain, there’s a stronger sense of trust and loyalty.
I’ve seen clients receive more thank-you messages, fewer refund requests, and even repeat purchases because BNPL made the first experience possible.
It also gives businesses more flexibility post-purchase. For example, it’s easier to offer upgrade paths, subscriptions, or add-ons when the initial purchase didn’t stretch the buyer’s budget.
In short: BNPL doesn’t just increase revenue. It deepens relationships. And that’s where the real long-term value kicks in.
Demographic Insights That Might Surprise You
Gen Z and Millennials are the most active adopters—but not necessarily because they’re cash-strapped. It’s more about control and convenience. They’ve grown up managing money digitally and expect optionality at checkout. For them, BNPL feels modern and empowering—not like a last resort.
Surprisingly, I’ve also seen strong uptake among higher-income B2B buyers—especially entrepreneurs and freelancers—who use BNPL to manage cash flow more efficiently. It’s not just about whether they can pay in full, but how they want to manage their money.
That said, transparency matters across the board. No one wants to feel tricked or upsold into debt. The clearer the terms—and the more trust you’ve built—the better the response, regardless of demographic.
Balancing Revenue Benefits with Responsibility
It starts with intentionality.
Just because BNPL can boost revenue doesn’t mean it should be used indiscriminately. Responsible implementation means thinking about your audience, your messaging, and the structure of your offers.
I advise against using BNPL to push unnecessary urgency or inflate pricing. Instead, use it to make genuinely valuable products or services more accessible—especially when those purchases support transformation, education, or well-being.
It’s also important to partner with BNPL providers that offer clear terms, transparent fees, and soft credit checks. Some even offer tools to help customers manage repayments responsibly.
Ultimately, it’s about long-term trust. When customers feel empowered—not pressured—they come back.
So the question isn’t just “How can BNPL help you sell more?” but “How can it help you serve more people well?”
Looking Forward
As BNPL continues to evolve, we’ll see more innovation in how businesses integrate these options into the customer journey. The most successful implementations will balance immediate revenue gains with long-term customer well-being.
For businesses considering BNPL, the data is clear: when implemented strategically, it drives significant growth while making your offerings more accessible to a broader audience.
But here’s the catch—it’s not just a payment method. It’s a positioning tool. A pricing strategy. A trust-builder.
The businesses that win with BNPL won’t be the ones chasing quick conversions. They’ll be the ones using it to deliver more value, build deeper relationships, and create an experience that buyers want to come back to.
Have you implemented BNPL in your business—or considered it? What results have you seen? What questions or hesitations are still on your mind? I’d love to hear your perspective—feel free to share your thoughts in the comments.
This article originally appeared in my Marketing Seeds newsletter. If you found it helpful, consider subscribing to receive weekly insights on strategic marketing and emerging AI capabilities—sent first to subscribers, before they’re published anywhere else.